Book a Call

The Hurt Is in the Judgment

The event is one thing. What you decide the event means is another thing entirely. And YOUR freedom is in the space between.

A still moment of reflection, learning to be quiet enough to choose your response

There's a line from Marcus Aurelius I keep coming back to. He wrote it nearly two thousand years ago, probably by candlelight, probably tired, probably carrying the weight of an empire he never asked for:

Remove the judgment, and you have removed the thought "I am hurt." Remove the thought "I am hurt," and the hurt itself is removed.

Marcus Aurelius

Read that again. Slowly.

He's not telling you the pain isn't real. He's telling you where it actually lives.

Where We Get It Wrong

Most of us walk around believing that other people hurt us. The coworker's comment. The text that never came. The look across the room. The decision that went the other way. We collect these moments like evidence, and we build a case, against them, against the world, sometimes against God.

And we drift. We drift into resentment. We drift into bitterness. We drift into a version of ourselves that's smaller, tighter, more guarded than the man or woman God actually made us to be.

But here's what Marcus Aurelius saw, and what I had to learn the hard way, both on the job and off it:

The event is one thing. What you decide the event means is another thing entirely.

He doubles down on this in another passage:

If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself but to your estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any moment.

Marcus Aurelius

At any moment. That's the part that should wake you up.

The Space Between

In my years in law enforcement, I watched this play out over and over. Two guys get cut off in traffic. One shrugs and keeps driving. The other follows the car for three miles with murder in his eyes. Same event. Two completely different lives downstream of it.

The event didn't choose their response. They did.

There's a space between what happens to you and what you do with it. That space is where your freedom lives. It's also where most of us never bother to show up. We skip it. We let the judgment form on autopilot, he disrespected me, she doesn't care, they're against me, and then we live as if that judgment is the truth about reality.

It isn't. It's a story. And you're the one telling it.

This Isn't Denial

Let me be clear about something, because I know how this can land wrong.

Marcus Aurelius isn't saying pretend nothing happened. He's not saying stuff it down, slap a smile on it, and call yourself fine. That's not Stoic. That's not Christian. That's just another kind of drift, the spiritual and emotional bypass kind.

What he is saying is this: before you carry the weight of being hurt, check the judgment that's asking you to carry it. Is it true? Is it the whole picture? Is it the story a man walking in his purpose would tell?

Because some of what you're carrying right now isn't the event. It's the verdict you handed down about the event. And you have the authority to revoke it.

What the Servant Knows

The greatest among you will be the servant of all. Not slave. Servant. There's a very important difference. One we often overlook. But that line has shaped how I think about leadership, and it shapes how I think about this too.

A servant doesn't have time to nurse every judgment. He's too busy doing the work in front of him. He sees the slight, notes it, sets it down, and moves on. Not because he's a doormat. Because he knows what he's about, and a stray comment from someone who doesn't know him doesn't get to set the terms of his day.

That's not weakness. That's the strongest thing in the room.

The Work

So here's the practice. Next time you feel the heat rise, the sting of a comment, the ache of being overlooked, the sharp edge of being misunderstood, pause before you render the verdict.

Ask yourself: What judgment am I about to make here? Is it true? Is it the one I want to live downstream of?

Then decide.

Because Marcus Aurelius was right. The hurt isn't in the event. The hurt is in the judgment. And the judgment is yours. The judgement one of the only things in this world you actually control.

Which means the freedom is too.

Matthew A. Buckley

Written by

Matthew A. Buckley

Former deputy sheriff, published author, and transformation coach. Matthew helps high-achievers stop drifting and build lives of intentional purpose through the proven Ditch the Drift framework. Sober since August 25, 2022.

Share this post: